ENGLISH DUB VS JAPANESE VERSION [here we go again]

[NelTu]

English: Full Metal Alchemist
Why?: Vic Mignogna


Japanese: Kuroshitsuji
why?: Because I never ever want to hear Sebastian open his mouth ans speak English at least not completely and with his cute Japanese accent. I love FUNimation for not ruining that for me.

[Sukunai]

I'm still in shock over season 3 Sailor Moon in English dub. I might never recover and it's been several years too.

But I confess, I don't mind dubbed anime as it allows me to 'watch' favourite shows while building models, as I am not required to 'read' the dialogue eh. I mean, ya, it would be so cool if I spoke fluent Japanese, but I don't.

I have no beef watching subbed anime, but I do occasionally get pissed off that sometimes I see the translation written differently than it is dubbed.

If the sentence is originally spoken in Japanese, the sentence translated into English will be written and spoken VIRTUALLY IDENTICALLY!! This is not open to debate, as my English language skills are not in question. Seeing an English sub different from the same language dubbed calls into doubt which was actually the valid interpretation. And ideally I want to know exactly what was originally was said.

[Taite]

I think they both suck. Chew on that for awhile.

[UpcomingDread]

I think they both suck. Chew on that for awhile.

Well here I some animes I preferred dubbed:

Trigun
Gurren Lagann
Baccano!
DBZ
Samurai Champloo
Hentalia
Cowboy Bebop
G Gundam
Yu Yu Hakusho

[uncreative]

I have no beef watching subbed anime, but I do occasionally get pissed off that sometimes I see the translation written differently than it is dubbed.

If the sentence is originally spoken in Japanese, the sentence translated into English will be written and spoken VIRTUALLY IDENTICALLY!! This is not open to debate, as my English language skills are not in question. Seeing an English sub different from the same language dubbed calls into doubt which was actually the valid interpretation. And ideally I want to know exactly what was originally was said.

This is actually relatively common, and the subs are generally the closer interpretation. Dubs usually try to work around the mouth movements of the characters, which can introduce a lot of fuzziness to the translation. This is also why Disney's releases of Ghibli movies usually have two subtitle tracks, one that's proper subtitles and one that is closed-captioning for the dub's dialogue.

[BasharOfTheAges]

I have no beef watching subbed anime, but I do occasionally get pissed off that sometimes I see the translation written differently than it is dubbed.

If the sentence is originally spoken in Japanese, the sentence translated into English will be written and spoken VIRTUALLY IDENTICALLY!! This is not open to debate, as my English language skills are not in question. Seeing an English sub different from the same language dubbed calls into doubt which was actually the valid interpretation. And ideally I want to know exactly what was originally was said.

This is actually relatively common, and the subs are generally the closer interpretation. Dubs usually try to work around the mouth movements of the characters, which can introduce a lot of fuzziness to the translation. This is also why Disney's releases of Ghibli movies usually have two subtitle tracks, one that's proper subtitles and one that is closed-captioning for the dub's dialogue.

In response to a lot of complaints about changing dialog, a number of dubbing studios actually started taking this idea and perverting it by just using the dub script for the subs and going "lol - what inconsistencies?"

[CodeZTM]

Honestly speaking, I've yet to see a translations/dubs that I just thought was "OMG. THEY BUTCHERED THE ENTIRE SHOW" with the exception of Cardcaptors (but that was more a complete re-haul of a show than a translation error). Most of the time, it's the actual character voices that matter to me, which is why Kaleido Star will ALWAYS make me cringe in horror when Layla talks.

Granted, I'll admit that most of the anime I watch is actually in English [with the exception of in the past several years where I began watching anime as it premiered in Japan]. I may have a completely different opinion once things like C: Money of Control gets english adapatations [IF they get adapted anyway], but recently I thought that DRRR! and Angel Beats pretty much hit the nail on the head for the most part.

[TEKnician]

Eureka Seven ENGLISH=WIN.
Even though that alot of the voices sounded similar (eg. Anemone, Holland, Talho) Johnny Young Bosch as Renton was hella good.

DRRR! and Angel Beats pretty much hit the nail on the head for the most part.

Key anime seems to reuse the same voice actors (Kanon->Clannad->Angel Beats).

[azulmagia]

The English dub of Urotsukidoji: The Legend of the Overfiend is HILARIOUS.

As for superior Japanese dubs...well, let's say there is a reason I don't watch Wedding Peach in English.

[8bit_samurai]

If I watch the English dub first, I would prefer it over the sub since more often than not, I most likely won't watch the sub anyways. I can get used to watching dubs of stuff I watched in subs first since it doesn't really bother me, but the thing that makes me cringes most is watching the same show that has a different dub than I'm used to, i.e. the Laughing Man and Individual Eleven OVAs.