Very good thread Omni! I'd gladly review some vids myself, but not in the same way as you - I can only judge them artistically, not technically. Still, if anyone wants that - I'm available.
***
And now to my purpose... Well, with quite a bit of caution and some obvious reservations, I guess I'll still go ahead and post the obvious for you:
http://animemusicvideos.org/members/mem ... hp?v=18517
Before you proceed (and not meant to sway your opinion any), a note of caution:
I
know this vid is technically deficient. I'm aware of most of the problems within it.
However, I still would appreciate an op from an expert, not so much to point out the obvious about this work, but to help me figure our where to go next (using this vid as a starting point).
I'll just say this: I made this video to serve an artistic/expressive purpose, not a technical one. If that caused it to violate what was taught by the great wise guides - I'm aware. But, shoganai - I'm now ready to face the music . I need to know what this AMV is, not what it's not. Please view and critique it for what it is.
In closing, a word from my musical hero -
Don't be helpful; be available. (RF)