While I've only been editing for a few months, I've been watching for years, and I have a good appreciation for some of the best AMVs out there that took real hard work to make. If you want an honest opinion that won't sugarcoat and not just some false praise, I'll be happy to let you know. I've seen the creme of the crop and bottom of the barrel and with me, 5 literally means average, just to let everyone know.
That being said, I'll happily give opinions to the first 10 videos in this thread, and only those that have a profile on the org and are completely finished. No betas.
If all this jives with you, leave a link! ^_^ I'm not requiring opinions in return, but I only have two vids so if you want to do me the favor then please feel free.