VCA Category suggestion Discussion

[Minion]

i actually like the "best inside joke" idea. was that sto's?

[SQ]

SQ A huge majority of those were The categories spammed from last year

Pay attention will you?

Pfft, I stopped paying attention to the VCAs in 2004.

[Reigna]

I don't think it's necessary, I think categories should be more on technical/skill merit than 'wow, it's hard to do an AMV to this genre of music.' If you allow this, then you'd have to allow "Best DBZ Video," "Best AMV Using An Anime Never Released On DVD", etc.

Agreed, even if it might be interesting to categorize things further, I think it would be hard to judge what people would consider Hip Hop, not to mention, as dokool said, it would open up the debate for hundreds of other specific categories.

[Kristyrat]

Yeah I agree with what the others have said, though it might increase the numbers of hip hop videos made, which could be cool since there are so few.