JCAs 2012 - Results are OUT! [on page 9~]

[TritioAFB]

Well after reviewing the 213 entries from AC, I guess I'm ready for this if you want me

[darkeldion]

me :

Spoiler :

Mims
Sa Robert
ThePooh

[ProjectBarcodeError]

Ha I remember the debates from last edition after the winners annoucements
So let's try to get more judges from different communities.

Mims
TritioAFB
S.A. Robert

i'm commander sheppard and this is my favorite proposition on this thread

Spoiler :

[drewaconclusion]

Should also probably consider having a judge who hasn't been too heavily involved in judging in the past (in any of the communities) just for the sake of bringing in a fresh prespective/wildcard.

[TritioAFB]

Actually I was thinking the same as mister Brisco. But just to make sure that the JCAs will work this time, you should also take someone as a moderator to the Judges just in case

[CodeZTM]

Actually I was thinking the same as mister Brisco. But just to make sure that the JCAs will work this time, you should also take someone as a moderator to the Judges just in case

Nya handled the moderation last year, and did a really nice job of it. I don't really see a reason to have another one.

[Shin-AMV]

Hmm a lot of good people I can think of. Makes it hard to choose. Here are my nominations though:

TritioAFB
CodeZTM
Mims

[drewaconclusion]

I'll nominate

Shin-AMV
RiderZ
zombie godix

[xLunax]

for me :

MimS
CodeZTM
S.A. Robert

[irriadin]

Here are my picks:

TritioAFB
CodeZTM
Shin-AMV

[Taite]

CodeZTM
Shin-AMV
TritioAFB

[TritioAFB]

I was wondering something Nya:

If one of the judges have problems with english, is he/she allowed to post his/her feedback in their native language?
There are some russians buddy that should try it. Besides, S.A. Robert will be more detailed in russian than in english I guess

[[madaraxD]]

Me:
Mims
CodeZTM
TritioAFB

[Radical_Yue]

Pwolf
mirkosp
Niotex
Diverse individual tastes and an eye for technical aspects. These three would present interesting choices and not be fooled by poor editing that's had a bucket of sparkles dumped on it.


Feel free to vote for me though I'd love to judge

[MimS]

Mirkosp
Snowcrash
Shin-AMV