Dr.Dinosaur wrote:Nya-chan Production wrote:MimS wrote:VCAs results suck but JCAs one are worse
Like every year, someone complains :>
But as I said, I plan to change the judge's selection for the next year - probably 7-9 judges, each from a different country. US, Russia, France and Italy will each get 1 place for sure :>
Well this year we had
I'd say that was pretty good.
They can came from peru it doesn't change anything, the main issue isn't their countries, but their friends, and their tastes. You can take 100 judges, if they all came from .org and have the same taste the result will always be the same. Let me sum up,
Members vote for their friends and then these friends (which became judges) vote for people who (their friends) elected them. Great, really.
Each year you will have the same judges, and the same kind of results.
You don't have to select the same judges each year, you'll save time, especially as : these judges have the same taste, don't take Miami lovers for judging the heat. I think i can tell which judges will be elected for the 2012 edition.
I don't blame judges, I know how it can be hard (I was judge for the past japan expo), and thanks for your verdict. The problem is : THE SYSTEM !!
I didn't criticize judges for their tastes it's a subjective opinion, we all have our own. I criticize the choice of judges.
Take 4 guys like :
Turbo, Dn@, JCD, Mirkosp...
And add 4 guys (or girls) elected by their friends.
And I think we will have more interesting results,
My 2 cents,