Backstory - I'm getting tired of the rather basic effects in Premiere (even though I might not know the full capability of it), so I thought that a good test would be a rather basic slideshow of still pics that I've completed in Premiere, and opening it in AE to see how it works.
I'm ASSUMING that anything Premiere can do, AE can do (and better). As in, there's no chance that AE won't recognise a Premiere effect.
I'm not actually up to the stage of learning effects - will be looking at tutorials for that.
So I went Import->File and double-clicked the sequence. Without touching anything, I went Composition -> Make Movie. And rendered in the render queue. Looking at the exported movie, first noticeable problem was that there was no sound. (I couldn't even see a sound setting in the render queue.) Second, some chunks were missing. :0 Just black where there should be pics.
Going back to AE, I could see that there was a clip where there's black, but it was pushed over to the right. Bringing it to where it should be still showed black. Expanding it, the keyframes were over to the left of where they should be. Highlighting them all and dragging them to the current time did show an image. But there is no 'snap' in AE, and it wasn't put back perfectly (I didn't really try, though)
First topic I found (through search): viewtopic.php?f=47&t=93754&p=1226941&hilit=after+effects+premiere#p1226941
blabber wrote:if you go file>import>import premiere project, or if you copy a sequence and paste it into an ae comp, you should keep your edits. however i never found this to be frame accurate, and it's a pain in the ass to trim everything back down.
also, any motion, fx or transitions you applied in premiere will probably be lost.
Yeah, it's not frame accurate, that's for sure. But I think the transitions are OK (although the fades are in red in AE, but I assume that's the specific colour for them)
If I've got to do all the work again, then it's not an option. XD
blabber wrote:cs4 dynamic link is where it's at, but you only get it in the production premium and master collection bundles. bridge is for managing your project files, it doesn't link between ae and ppro.
I've got CS3, so that's out.
blabber wrote:another option is to export an edl (edit decision list) from premiere, and import that into ae.
I did export an EDL, but going through Google and such, I can't see how to open it in AE. :/ (Import->File doesn't recognise EDL as a usable type)
blabber wrote:best way is to work scene by scene though - render out or copy/paste the clips you need from ppro into an ae comp, do the work over there, then render out with project link enabled. bring the rendered output into your premiere timeline to replace the original clips.
I actually can't follow that. ^^; And besides, with the next vid that will hopefully combine still pics and select footage, there will be so many effects that I'd like to use AE without having to use Premiere for effects.
(but does that mean that you can have any AE effect in Premiere? That would be awesome)
Second problem was that I couldn't hear any sound in AE. Thanks to this topic viewtopic.php?f=47&t=76213&hilit=after+effects+sound
pressing the . key on the numpad played sound, 0 key to render workspace. *phew*
Anyway, I rendered again and absolutely no sound in the export. :/
BauziOLD wrote:Demux your audio from the video stream.
Open VDM and click on streamlist to export your .wav audio. There you have. A single soundfile in wav.
I can't follow that. ^^; (means in another program, not AE?) And besides, I'm using an mp3 for sound, no video attached.
However, I do know how to export in WAV format from Premiere, so that's not a problem - I could get the audio fixed first and into one file, then work off that. (and Premiere can't export in mp3 - it's simply not an option XD) I don't know if AE can export in mp3 because I can't get it to export any audio. I can't even see an option to just export audio.
So, I hope it's clear that I've tried to do some research, but still... at this point I'd really appreciate some specialist advice. There are so many options, and I'm not sure how to approach it. Thanks to anyone! ^^