by Nya-chan Production » Mon Jan 26, 2009 1:29 pm
Recapitulation of the betas:
_Sanchez_:
Nice idea, length of :53. Sadly has to be rebuilt from the scratch.
Idea: 4/5
Technical:5/5
Editing: 3/5
Ghet:
Kind of creepy :/ Length 0:26, not bad. Could be maybe cleaned a little, but let's leave that for final.
Idea: 2-3/5
Technical: 4/5
Editing: 4/5
grandbahamut:
Hardcuts work too. 12s of nice and calm cuts, maybe too quick in succession, but it's not bad. Source of good qaulity.
Idea: 4/5
Technical: 4-5/5 (sadly not WS, maybe upscale would be better... then again, maybe not)
Editing: 4/5
Ingow:
Awesome 3:10 of beta. What I didn't like much was the fact that it was made of one ep only, some other bits into it might freshen it up a little. Still, nice mellow/sad piece. Source pretty good. Some cuts could use a bit of work.
Idea: 4/5
Technical: 4-5/5
Editing: 4/5
koopiskeva:
Master of ideas. I liked what I saw, even when it was short (12s), not scaled yet and with no cuts.
Idea: 5/5
Technical: 3-4/5 (clear, not scaled nor bordered)
Editing: N/A
LeapofFate:
25s of awsmsauce, one of my favourites. Quality right up there, beautiful idea, precise editing with only some to-be-fixed spots.
Idea: 5/5
Technical: 5/5
Editing: 4/5
Megamom:
Two betas, both of full 1:25. Very nice idea, though the concentration on story only is a little drawback. Improvement over the betas (side disturbing is a plus, sometimes) and main them is what I like. High quality is a given.
Idea: 4/5
Technical: 5/5
Editing: 5/5
Meroko fan: N/A. If you wanna see your rating for beta, say so.
Niwa:
:14 of great, beautiful, calm feel. Don't have ANYTHING to say. The best one.
Idea: 5/5
Technical: 5/5
Editing: 5/5
Pas:
His first editing work (same with grandbahamut, btw). 56s of very nice editing. Some parts would need a little brush over, but very nice. Overall idea he told me and I found it veeery fitting.
Idea: 5/5
Technical: 5/5
Editing: 4/5
Phlu (prebeta):
8s of one scene only. Work, man!
Idea: 4(?)/5
Technical: 3-4/5 (clean, clean, clean)
Editing: N/A
Taokato:
29s of disturbing. Dunno if it's the right way to grasp this theme, but dunno yet. Technical skyhigh, even when 4:3. Editing very good, nice use of effects.
Idea: 3(?)/5
Technical: 4-5/5
Editing: 5/5
TOHH:
Nice idea, innovative, 37s. Still pretty boring/mellov (the piece with food is great). Some technical issues, which will be solved, as he told me.
Idea: 5/5
Technical: 3/5 so far
Editing: 4/5
Vax:
Full beta (1:24) , best approach about betaing, sent me 4 pieces and improved over them. Third of my favourites so far. In the end almost perfect editing, very good source (and I have seen wmv only so far) and great mellow feel. Hope he can work out a lossless.
Idea: 5/5
Technical: 4-5/5
Editing: 5/5
That said, important announcement!
There are two tracks free (see the first post). BUT, if you want a track that hasn't given me beta yet, while being signed up from the start (namely ArashinomeAMV's and Otohiko's), you can do the beta as well. If I like it and they don't give me nothing before you do, you'll be taken instead of them. This doesn't count for those who are already signed up, sorry :<
The final beta term will be announced once I have ALL the betas from you (and as you have seen, the beta time limit is rather short, so go go go!)