
InspZenigata wrote:This is a freakin great idea. The reworked AMV Salad3 flows much better and actually funnier than the initial BETA. I think if we used that idea, the L&O bits could put it over the top!
I say go for it.
Gaelstrom wrote:Awesomeness, glad it gets a trial run. Are you going to get audience reactions and stuff so we can see how they take it?
Speaking of which I watched it again and wanted to suggest the addition of test patterns between clips at 4:49, 5:28, 6:54, 10:10, 14:07 (also there's two seconds of dead space after the clip that breaks the flow), 14:53, 15:47, and 16:08 (You can cut off a bit of the silence with the Men's Wearhouse logo too, added it in for that reason). Also, I'm not sure if it'll help or hurt, but I'd also suggest trying to add test patterns between the clips before the bumps and the bumps themselves to hear how it sounds. It may give a bit extra to the clips or it may be too much.
Also I'm confused about the german clip, Krvabo... honestly I don't know what it is. I had to check the credits to find out what it's from, watch the MTV Gunther commercial, and still don't understand what it's trying to do. It doesn't show her saying she's german, so I don't feel any connection. Also, it looks like the audio's really off at the beginning, then syncs up when he/she goes 'sheizer' if I use the original as a determinant. Can you explain what you're trying to do?
deuceloosely wrote:I intentionally left the test patterns out before and after each set of commercials. Those separators were only to signify that the segments of "regular" clips are part of AMV Salad and the commercials / bumpers are there to interrupt the show. Placing the separators in between the commercials would negate the effect of watching an [adult swim] programming slot.
Gaelstrom wrote:And have you considered that the AS bump that goes after Tim and Eric, Drinky Crow, etc. may alienate audience members who actually like those shows? It's subjective of course. Many people like Tim and Eric for often inexplicable reasons, and could make some people uncomfortable and ruin the mood a bit.




krvabo wrote:To be honest I dislike the Günther clip myself.
It was the first commercial I tried and I even edited it (the original audio). When Deuce said we shouldn't I forgot about it and went on to other clips (which turned out a lot better; hyakko - reservoir dogs and haruhi - guitar hero).
Really, the video looks a lot better when watching the original, but when put in the salad it just.. looks horrendous. It's actually pretty well synced.
The joke might be lost when you don't know the original commercial.




deuceloosely wrote:The "match.com" and "Now 63" were made with WMM2, meaning WMV files.
deuceloosely wrote:Seriously, it's inconsistency that weighs down a project like this. It's no one's fault that we all can't work with the same editing programs but there are other things that can be done to make sure higher quality standards are met and consistency among the clips is maintained...


InspZenigata wrote:I'll be sorting out that DVD ripping problem once school starts up again. I want to submit some decent quality stuff here, but hopefully the comedic value and/or well-timed value of the clips will make up for it. I just don't have the money to spend on this as it's just a hobby.
Return to Multi-Editor Projects
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests