1) the bones are found in the basement.
2) someone claims they're hers but won't actually look at them.
3) another girl comes along and .. also knows they're down there?
3a) the 2nd girl can see the first girl.
3b) the first girl knows who the 2nd girl is.
3c) the 2nd girl does not see the first girl as pretty but as a black disaster!
3d) the 2nd girl is crying in the same position as the dead girls found body.
3e) the first girl will not go down there!?
.. deductive conclusion: the 2nd girl IS THE GIRL who died down there.
1) the bones are found in the basement.
2) someone claims they're hers but won't actually look at them.
3) another girl comes along and .. also knows they're down there?
3a) the 2nd girl can see the first girl.
3b) the first girl knows who the 2nd girl is.
3c) the 2nd girl does not see the first girl as pretty but as a black disaster!
3d) the 2nd girl is crying in the same position as the dead girls found body.
3e) the first girl will not go down there!?
.. deductive conclusion: the 2nd girl IS THE GIRL who died down there.
Spoiler :
Not really no, just how did you get to that conclusion?!
First and foremost, the "second" girl, Kirie, did not know about the corpse being in the basement, she was told by Niiya.
Anyway, Kirie is the grand-daughter of the younger sister of the "first" girl, Yuuko, as she stated herself, and that was not a lie. This is more or less the reason why she can see Yuuko.
Moreover, Kirie can clearly be seen by normal people without any special condition in place, as Momoe can see her at any given time, so that's just further proof that she is not a ghost.
That said, the corpse they found in the basement isn't necessarily Yuuko's corpse either, anything they say about it is mere speculation at this point in time.
Tritio: I'm following the manga, trust me when I say he got it wrong. I can even guess where they're going to stop with the anime, too... and it would make sense.
mirkosp wrote:Tritio: I'm following the manga, trust me when I say he got it wrong. I can even guess where they're going to stop with the anime, too... and it would make sense.
Yuuko trolling Niiya with that rock or the scene where Kirie handed around cards for 4 people instead of 3 not to mention the tension of wanting to see the next episode with the Shadow standing above Kirie...
Did somebody noticed that episode 4 was weird in the way that it looked like Nisemogatari? I mean the aspect ratio at certain moments of the episode reminded me to Nisemo.
TritioAFB wrote:Did somebody noticed that episode 4 was weird in the way that it looked like Nisemogatari? I mean the aspect ratio at certain moments of the episode reminded me to Nisemo.
It's funny to me how everyone notices how Silver Link is related to SHAFT for this show but didn't as much for C3 and BakaTest. But it's true that there are lots of little things all over the place that should remind you of SHAFT shows, and also of BakaTest (like the flashing earrings).
not to mention the tension of wanting to see the next episode with the Shadow standing above Kirie... 
