TritioAFB wrote:I'll comment detailed once I'm done with my duties with AKROSS. For the moment, some of my friends that watched the video said that it was good
diegao94 wrote:I liked it! I haven't fully understood it, but you did a pretty nice job! Good luck in the contest!
irriadin wrote:I enjoyed the mood and atmosphere. Good use of instrumental. However, I can't help but feel that the video is a bit lacking in substance. There doesn't seem to be anything more to it than what is written in the video description. Why the boy cares about the girl, what the girl represents to him... we don't know and I feel like the scene selection doesn't bring the amount of mystery it should. So I appreciate the technical side of things, but the story really didn't do much for me. Good luck!
xDreww wrote:I liked it. :3 Technical was very nice, good editing all around. Cept for the story could have been a bit more detailed in my opinion. Thats just the only flaw I have. But pretty great edit though. Good luck. :3
Shin-AMV wrote:Its hard to make an instrumental AMV and keep it interesting enough for me to watch from start to finish. I managed to watch it all, good vibe and some nice technical work.
nihilant01 wrote:Stunning amv.
I love blue and sparkling videos, and the plot is quite easy to understand, even if it could be told better: it would have been more interesting if you showed what kind of relationship there was between the boy and the "ghost" girl.
However I really enjoyed this, it's not easy to combine different sources that good. Good luck for the contest!
Theredflash66 wrote:Nicely done
-Kyros- wrote:I'm not very clear concept, but you did a really good job
good luck for the contest
Animated wrote:Since I've been praising you during beta-testing, here's what's more I have to say:Spoiler :
Great, great job Eve Best of luck on Akross, go kick some ass!
(and get back to your TTT part, now!)
Milk Or Life! wrote:<3
So... do You want cookie as a reward ?
bombush wrote:First of all: Awesome job!
Now that I got that out of my system, let's get a little more specific...
I loved every bit of the video, including the story. With the recent abundance of crossover videos with tight storytelling following pretty much the same pattern of unrequited/tragic love, what you did felt like a breath of fresh air. A storytelling video built solely on emotions, a mystery but unpretentious amv. I understand it's not everyone's cup of tea but the vague storytelling was precisely what made the atmosphere so strong. I actually even felt that the photo frame at the end was telling too much, and since it is a very concrete and in crossover videos overused object it felt kind of disrupting to the whole mystery atmosphere.
Anyways... loved it!
EDIT: just please don't make your storytelling too easy to understand. I want to see more videos like this one^^
Cecco wrote:Awesome centu!
Nya-chan Production wrote:Everyone is abusing Oreki... Poor Chitanda ;___;
MagicDarkLight wrote:I liked it, the blue feeling is cool, the implementation of the different animes and how you managed to make it burst when the music finally takes off Could have been smoother and cleaner at some parts but it was ok overalls. Good job and good luck in Akross!
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests