Sukunai, Real Canadian Hero wrote:Note to any Muslims present. Abuse a female in my presence, and you are being sent to a hospital emergency ward with life threatening injuries. And no human law will make me change my mind.

LittleAtari wrote:The only thing I'm confused about is, are you having the judges pull the winners from the finalist list? I was going to recommend going with at least the semi finalist list since that's a bigger pool of videos. It still provides a comparison to the VCAs because it throws in the possibility that semi finalist can surpass a finalist in certain categories, which could be interesting.

godix partially wrote:
The rules:
- (left out)
- (left out)
- The pool of videos to be judged will be the VCA semi-finalists. Since not all videos were qualified for the VCAs judges will have the option of adding one video of their choice to any category. Each judge will view these videos and rank the top five in each category, assigning 5 points to the best down to 1. I then added up those points per category and, hopefully, post the winners right after the VCA results are announced.
- Judges will not allowed to vote in the categories they're nominated in.
- In the event of a tie I will act as a tie breaker, otherwise I will not be involved in the judging.
- The judges will remain anonymous during the voting process, it will be announced who they were once the results are posted.
- Judges will be asked to make a few brief comments on the videos they select. Some of those comments may be used publicly (EG, in the results thread) but will not be attributed. To address something that came up last year, I will not attribute any comments and will not release how individual judges voted. If the judges themselves choose to do that then they're certainly free to.
- (left out)
- There are no prizes other than bragging rights.

Infinity Squared wrote:LittleAtari wrote:The only thing I'm confused about is, are you having the judges pull the winners from the finalist list? I was going to recommend going with at least the semi finalist list since that's a bigger pool of videos. It still provides a comparison to the VCAs because it throws in the possibility that semi finalist can surpass a finalist in certain categories, which could be interesting.
Actually, I was thinking the same thing... wasn't it from teh semi-finalist pool the other years or not?

LittleAtari wrote:The only thing I'm confused about is, are you having the judges pull the winners from the finalist list? I was going to recommend going with at least the semi finalist list since that's a bigger pool of videos. It still provides a comparison to the VCAs because it throws in the possibility that semi finalist can surpass a finalist in certain categories, which could be interesting.
But I'm interested in what will happen with videos categories in which videos were 'misplaced.' For instance, the 'Acid Star' collab in the MEP section or 'Eureka Sunlight' being in the No Effects category when it clearly uses effects.
Sukunai, Real Canadian Hero wrote:Note to any Muslims present. Abuse a female in my presence, and you are being sent to a hospital emergency ward with life threatening injuries. And no human law will make me change my mind.

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests