TheUnlimited wrote:if it's to remaster or remake an old video.. then it shouldn't change the originality.
SuperFusion wrote:Depends on how many vids I saw using the same song, theme, and how well you executed it
bum wrote:SuperFusion wrote:Depends on how many vids I saw using the same song, theme, and how well you executed it
Did you even bother to read the first post?
Keeper of Hellfire wrote:I'd make a difference between remaster and remake. Remaster is only a quality improvement, so it's still the same video and should be given the same originality. A remake is a new video, so it should get it's own judgement on originality. It depends now on the changes you've made. Mostly it should get a lower originality, since the idea already was done. But if for example the way you applied the effects is something new, it can get of course a higher originality.
SuperFusion wrote:bum wrote:SuperFusion wrote:Depends on how many vids I saw using the same song, theme, and how well you executed it
Did you even bother to read the first post?
Yeah, I did. And I responded to his question as I would've saw fit to rate his video.
Maverick-Rubik wrote:SuperFusion wrote:bum wrote:SuperFusion wrote:Depends on how many vids I saw using the same song, theme, and how well you executed it
Did you even bother to read the first post?
Yeah, I did. And I responded to his question as I would've saw fit to rate his video.
And I tend to agree with SuperFusion...
Originality means coming up with the concept first- which he did. To put it crudely, it means not ripping anyone else off... which he wouldn't have done if he originally (!) made it.
Making the same thing again won't make it an unoriginal creation as long as it was original to begin with. So it depends on how many vids I saw to the same song, if the theme has been done before, and how well it was executed.
Knowname wrote:Hmm... one more example... ever seen underwear worn over your pants? That'd be original cuz it's never DONE! Most wouldn't say 'Wow! How original!' to that guy, most would just call him a geek... Now why would you have high originality points... yet low everything else (sense of style ;p), what USE is that score?? That's what I mean, the name 'originality' may be too confuseing, it doesn't mean ORIGINALity, but effectiveness like you said.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests