Castor Troy wrote:1's for Sammy, 10's for me.
thats bold words.. he made some great crappy videos, and all you have is some crummy cross yaoi DZB video about Goku and Manfaye.. not to mention the Mario yaoi scenes..
Castor Troy wrote:1's for Sammy, 10's for me.
godix wrote:Recently I've been trying to cram as many different ways of saying 'your video sucks' as I can in ops. I used to not leave those types of ops but what can I say, I've noticed a re-occuring element to most videos I see.
When I take ops seriously I do a catagory by catagory breakdown. I find everything I have to say is covered under one of the catagories and since I tend to be below average (why the fuck is an 8 average given below the sites average anyway?) I find it helps avoid complaints if I explain each score.
(map (lambda (x) (cons x (+ 1 (random 10)))) grading-criteria)
inthesto wrote:How do your ops work?
Well, for starters, my opinions tend to run around 1000 words. Then, I do it like this:
"Good Points:
See General Comments.
Bad Points:
See General Comments.
General Comments:
Before I begin, I'd like to make the following comments, which IN NO WAY impact on your scores (except Re-viewable). 1. <some comment about the anime or game - whether I like it or not.> 2. <some comment about the song - whether I like it or not.> 3. Anyway, onto the review!
Originality - score #
-----------------------------
- comments on use (or overuse) of anime, song, concept
Capture/Output Quality - # -
----------------------------------
comments
Sound Quality - #
--------------------------
- comments
Action/Editing Sync -
--------------------------
# - my most important category. I divide it into mood sync and beat sync. So, even if one half of the equation was crap, I may still score decently if I think the other half was good.
Lip Sync - #
------------------------
- comments, if it's even in the video. If so, I drop points for extra or not enough mouth movements. Also, I drop points for mouth movements if they are not synched to anything in a video with lip. If there is no lip in the video, I could care less if the mouths are moving.
Digital Effects - # -
--------------------------
comments (if they're even in the video)
Effort - #
--------------------------------
- a category I hate, because no one really knows how much effort another put in. I usually look to the video description for this score. If they seemed excited about the idea and the product was halfway decent, I usually give a good score.
Overall - #
------------------------------
- my general idea of the video. Rehash of the few improvements I think it could use and what was done well.
Re-viewable - #
--------------------------
- an eight here is a ten in any other category for me. The comments that I make in the beginning of the opinion sometimes come into play here also.
<paragraph detailing my thoughts on the person as a creator - where I think he/she is going, if he/she seems to be improving. A general thought on the video. Sometimes, a funny comment about how jealous I am of his/her great work or idea.> Anyway...
As always, Farewell, Good Luck, and Happy AMV-ing!
PS: <sometimes a comment on the filesize, or a random, amusing comment>"
JaddziaDax wrote:you know you can cut and pasteit will work on your usefulness score too!
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests