Noobie AMV pitfalls - advice from the veterans?

This forum is for the general discussion of Anime Music Videos.

Postby megaman917 » Sun May 08, 2005 12:20 am

808-buma wrote:and yes, I realize that most first-time AMV's will suck big time, but I just don't want mine to suck too much. Thanks for all the advice - and keep them coming! Us noobies need to know this!


That is not necessarily true, because I've seen many a first AMV that were great. + If you keep thinking like that your first AMV will suck big time.
"If you're not cheating, you're not trying!" - R.I.P. Eddie Guerrero (1967 - 2005)
Through tragedy, she found triumph. R.I.P. Coretta Scott King (1927 - 2006)
Long live the "King of Pop"! R.I.P. Michael Jackson (1958 - 2009)
User avatar
megaman917
 
Joined: 27 Aug 2004
Location: Brooklyn, NY
Status: Psychotic, but Sociable

Postby 808-buma » Sun May 08, 2005 12:25 am

IcyCloud wrote:A few of the mistakes I've seen in first videos :
- Subtitles. Using downloaded footage in itself is a no-no, but even moreso if you leave the subtitles in. That's just lazy.
- DivX logo (or fansub group/GameSpot logos). If you follow the compression guide, you should be DivX logo-free. As in the above case, if you're using downloaded footage and it's got a logo, crop it out or use LogoAway.
- Lip flap. Unless you're lip-syncing, having mouths moving is distracting from your video.
- Rough or no deinterlacing/IVTC. Some scripts work better than others, so it's important to experiment to find which gives you the best results.
- Off timing. Pay careful attention to the beats and be consistent.

Those are the most prevalent ones I've come across, anyhow.


sorry, missed this in the above reply -
Two questions on the above:

1. I know what you mean about 'random lip flapping' but I'm supposing that if it isn't centered on the screen (the focal point of the scene occuring), would it be passible? For example, one shot I'm using (from GitS), is a closeup of Motoko's chest as she is gearing up, but at the top of the screen, you can see the bottom of her face and she is talking to someone. The main view of the screen is her gearing up, so would that be okay, in general (as I know unless you've seen GitS a hundred times or actually used the scene, you may not be familiar with it)?

2. I'm somewhat confused by the guides about interlaced vids. Currently, I'm editing directly with the VOB files that are, as I understand it, progressive (and interlaced, right?). So, if my final output from all these VOB files is still a dvd compliant VOB file, I can skip the de-interlacing, right? Or am I missing something?

Thanks again
User avatar
808-buma
 
Joined: 25 Apr 2005

Postby AquaSky » Sun May 08, 2005 2:37 am

1.) Lip flap is distracting no matter where on the screen it is occuring. Fortunately, most instances can be covered by masking (unless it's a high-motion scene or the like).

2.) VOBs can be either interlaced/telecined or fully progressive, but not both. Very few anime DVDs are encoded progressively, and to my knowledge, GitS is not one of them. Therefore, you must inverse telecine (or deinterlace, whichever method you choose). I think you may be a bit confused about encoding; your end video will have an .avi extension (or .mpg, .wmv, etc.), not VOB. In short, can't skip the deinterlacing, but it's not terribly difficult to do - just use the guides and you'll be fine.
User avatar
AquaSky
Master of Science
 
Joined: 15 Apr 2003
Location: Palm Beach Gardens, FL.

Postby FoxJones » Sun May 08, 2005 2:58 am

IcyCloud wrote:- Lip flap. Unless you're lip-syncing, having mouths moving is distracting from your video.


I still see this as a viewer's problem, not a technical screw up. It's a symptom from the disease called over-using-lip-sync-in-every-other-darn-AMV ;)
Though, this differs depending of the AMV's concept. There are some situations where lip flapping will bother, but then again there are times when it does not bother at all and whining about it seems really odd to me. Though several of the latter cases are fully instrumental AMVs. I for one thing usually want SOMETHING to happen in the video. If the lip flapping supports the music it's more acceptable than using static person-just-sits-there-with-his/her-jaw-open just that there wouldn't be any lip flap. Better example for this would be.. There's a scene in a drama AMV where two people are having a intense conversation.. like arguing over something. Now.. they are showing great emotion and this supports the song's pacing and the over feeling of the musical piece or follows up the story the artist wanted to tell in his/her AMV. If there's singing now and it isn't lip synced.. if this is called annoying lip flapping I really just have to rise an eyebrow for this.. o.ô
Let's take the same scene and lip sync it. Now the scenes are enslaved by the lyrics and might give whole different meaning to the AMV itself. Well.. "fck that, now there's no lip flapping" -> o(-_-#)
(just rambling of a story-telling asshole artist you guys should ignore..)

Long message short: Point is that lip sync/lip flap are NOT a good thing/problem as such. It's how they are imbedded in the AMV.
Image
User avatar
FoxJones
The foxiest!
 
Joined: 19 Aug 2003
Location: Lieto, Finland

Postby godix » Sun May 08, 2005 3:09 am

I basically agree with FoxJones. If you have a far off shot with stuff happening in the background, a crowd shot, or some other clip where the focus isn't on the lips then lip flap is no big deal, hell there's a decent chance no one even notices. OTOH if you have a closeup of one characters face and they're flapping their gums for no reason then it's a problem. So basically it all depends on the scene and how noticable the lip flap is.
Image
User avatar
godix
a disturbed member
 
Joined: 03 Aug 2002

Postby 808-buma » Sun May 08, 2005 3:31 am

megaman917 wrote:That is not necessarily true, because I've seen many a first AMV that were great. + If you keep thinking like that your first AMV will suck big time.

Well, I don't think it will suck <fingers crossed> :D - just wanted to attempt to make sure that the viewing public won't think it sucks. At least I can avoid 'obvious noobie' mistakes...

IcyCloud wrote:I think you may be a bit confused about encoding; your end video will have an .avi extension (or .mpg, .wmv, etc.), not VOB. In short, can't skip the deinterlacing, but it's not terribly difficult to do - just use the guides and you'll be fine.


Well, yes, the end downloadable product will probably be an .AVI file, but I'm using <gasp> Nero Vision Express 3 as my editor which produces VOB files as an end product. From there I'm pretty sure I have to use VDMod with AVISynth to help produce a good looking final. And, as far as I remeber, AVISynth will allow me to de-interlace (I think).

And about the 'remote' lip-flapping, I guess we'll have to see if it is distracting - just made a 'test' VOB file to see my progress so far (about 2 minutes into it right now - 3 minutes to go!).
User avatar
808-buma
 
Joined: 25 Apr 2005

Postby Arigatomina » Sun May 08, 2005 4:47 am

FoxJones wrote:There are some situations where lip flapping will bother, but then again there are times when it does not bother at all and whining about it seems really odd to me.

Long message short: Point is that lip sync/lip flap are NOT a good thing/problem as such. It's how they are imbedded in the AMV.

You know, I've heard a few people say this in a recent thread as well - that lip flap is expected in vids and that an amv without lip movement is just odd. I wonder if these people give reviews.

The first constructive suggestion I received in a review was to cut out the lip flap. No mention of quality or poor editing - the lip flap was the first thing that stood out. Since then I've consistently gotten complaints on the rare occassion that I leave lip movements in a video (maybe 1 second in every 30minutes of amvs I've made). It doesn't matter how rarely I do it - if I do it, the reviewers will notice and complain about it.

That tells me for most viewers (at least - the viewers who leave reviews), you don't have lip movements unless it's lip synced to match the lyrics. Otherwise, expect to have people tell you to cut the lip flap the same way they tell you to cut the subtitles.

Do it if you want, though. I know a few people who actually like subtitles since they tell you what's going on in an anime you've never seen - making it easier to 'get' the video made from that anime. I guess if lips flapping up and down tell you something constructive, they can serve a similar purpose.

/my 'don't do'

Don't lip sync a serious song. It kills the mood and makes it seem silly. If I'm watching a dramatic video that makes me actually feel for the character, I'm going to be thrown right out of that the moment the character starts singing along with the music. It's like watching a movie with a dramatic song playing - only to have the actor pull an "Earth Girls Are Easy" lip sync section on me. Yeah, it's fun to watch, but not in a tear-jerking drama video.
User avatar
Arigatomina
 
Joined: 03 Apr 2003

Postby AquaSky » Sun May 08, 2005 7:26 am

FoxJones wrote:Let's take the same scene and lip sync it. Now the scenes are enslaved by the lyrics and might give whole different meaning to the AMV itself.

I'm not advocating lip-sync as the solution to lip flap here - I'm talking in terms of lyric sync. And of course you wouldn't want to see a 5-second still shot with no movement, but that obviously calls for a different scene choice or trimming the clip - there are more effective ways of adding motion than lip flap. Eh, call me old-fashioned, but when I see yammering all over the place, it seems like there was a lack of effort on the editor's part. That's my standpoint on it, anyhow.
User avatar
AquaSky
Master of Science
 
Joined: 15 Apr 2003
Location: Palm Beach Gardens, FL.

Postby staces » Sun May 08, 2005 11:18 pm

Ah, lip flapping, the newest peeve to join my collection of pets. ^^;; While I agree that it's annoying, unless maybe it's like showing someone scream during a really emotional part of a song or something, or synching a word like "laughter" with a clip of the character laughing.

Anyways, I as a very lazy editor, usually take care of my lip flapping issues in a way that's easier than masking (in other words, in a way that doesn't require good software). Easier than masking the mouth and leaving a person standing there forever, is just deleting the frames with lip movement. I mean, make sure that you don't delete anything that would make it jerky (or add in a few still frames to keep the pace) but if you just get rid of the frames of talking and keep the motion you can have the good parts of the clip without the bad and not have your AMV be comprised of a long series of still shots. ^^;;

I hope that made sense, I'm not very good at explaining crap.
Image
ImageImage
User avatar
staces
 
Joined: 01 Sep 2003
Location: California

Postby FoxJones » Mon May 09, 2005 7:18 am

IcyCloud wrote:Eh, call me old-fashioned, but when I see yammering all over the place, it seems like there was a lack of effort on the editor's part. That's my standpoint on it, anyhow.


Funny.. I thought I was old-fashioned, going out against stuff like lip-sync and over-effecting which are considered nowadays more as a rule than exception ;)
Image
User avatar
FoxJones
The foxiest!
 
Joined: 19 Aug 2003
Location: Lieto, Finland

Postby Vlad G Pohnert » Mon May 09, 2005 1:54 pm

Don't put in effects to impress people, use effects only when it's required or it actually enhances what your are trying to do. There is nothing wrong with using effects, But these days almost every 5th video must has some sort of effect distortion, flying boxes, moving frames, or even the simple flash to every single BEAT with no real purpose except to signify the beats or be impressive... I so sick of watching those. It's fine if that is what you want to do as this is a hobby, BUT don't expect everyone to think of how great it is...

And you don't have to try to do something on EVERY SINGLE BEAT. This is another illusion that lots of editors feel is a requirement. I've even gotten points taken off my videos in the opinions because I was told I missed one or two beats (and I don't mean accidentally) :roll:

Vlad
User avatar
Vlad G Pohnert
 
Joined: 02 Jan 2001
Location: Edmonton, Alberta, Canada

Postby trythil » Mon May 09, 2005 2:08 pm

FoxJones wrote:
IcyCloud wrote:Eh, call me old-fashioned, but when I see yammering all over the place, it seems like there was a lack of effort on the editor's part. That's my standpoint on it, anyhow.


Funny.. I thought I was old-fashioned, going out against stuff like lip-sync and over-effecting which are considered nowadays more as a rule than exception ;)


Actually, I think current wisdom is that Going Against The Flow makes you more l33t.
This is a block of text that can be added to posts you make. There is a 512 character limit.
trythil
is
 
Joined: 23 Jul 2002
Location: Llanfairpwllgwyngyllgogerychwyrndrobwllllantysiliogogogoch

Postby Beowulf » Mon May 09, 2005 2:37 pm

trythil wrote:
Actually, I think current wisdom is that Going Against The Flow makes you more l33t.


Indubitably.
User avatar
Beowulf
 
Joined: 27 Feb 2002
Location: in the art house

Postby Bakadeshi » Mon May 09, 2005 6:41 pm

staces wrote:Ah, lip flapping, the newest peeve to join my collection of pets. ^^;; While I agree that it's annoying, unless maybe it's like showing someone scream during a really emotional part of a song or something, or synching a word like "laughter" with a clip of the character laughing.


I agree on this note aswell. Certain scenes of showing anger or conflict can be apropriate to leave the talking in the scene. The same could go for a lovy-dovy scene where it looks like the character is saying something sweet to the other character, provided its strategically placed in the song so its doesn't look like the character is singing the song. Also what godix said about people in a large crowd just conversing, thats normal to not expect to hear what they are saying exactly, since normally the brain automatically sees these scenes as not important.

Lip flapping can be anoying when theres too much of it, but in certain cases, its usually plausable if you edit it so that the lip isn't flapping endlessly, like mask over the parts that are easy to mask, and leave the ones on motion scenes that make it more dificult to mask, will be alot better than leaving it alone completely. If the song is instrumental aswell, or its an instrumental part of the song, generally you can also get away with lipflap. Its when it looks like the character might be trying to sing along with the song when its inapropriate, or badbly timed like a bad kung fuu movie is when its realy distracting and anoying.
User avatar
Bakadeshi
Abuses Spellcheck
 
Joined: 29 Sep 2003
Location: Atlanta, GA

Postby madbunny » Mon May 09, 2005 7:22 pm

Instead of trying to focus on a myriad of funky little things that you'll pick up over time anyway, like lip sync, beat matching, or deinterlacing... you should just focus on being able to tell your story creatively.

Essentially, if you want to be good, and unique you have to figure out what works for you.

My advice: find someone that you trust to not sugarcoat things, and still be constructive to do betas for you while you're getting the hang of it.

Also, the best way to be able to spot stuff is to give lots of opinions, detailed opinions on other peoples videos. Then, while you're making your own you should be able to spot some of the 'more or less' common things that pop up.
User avatar
madbunny
 
Joined: 17 Jun 2003

PreviousNext

Return to General AMV

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests