first off, I wasn't planning to make this thread, but since I am feeling a bit looked down upon, I am making this thread anyway. This is about me, giving my honest opinion on an AMV, and getting an negative, slightly aggressive reaction from the editor on it. Well, that, on itself, did not bother me that much. But now a friend of his (aka a judge on almost all Dutch AMV Conventions) is suddenly starting to bash on my videos. I am not trying to make these editors look bad, but I feel that what his friend is doing now is just unfair and harsh towards me.
The AMV I commented on: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ctqxaw5c-Eo
This was the conversation I and the editor had:
This was what I received today as a comment on my comment.
Then I got a comments on 2 of my most recent dutch convention amvs.
(since these conversations are in dutch I have translated them)
This is my AMV he commented on: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=25RrO3Cwgq8
To clarify why I never asked for feedback, my sister has done that for her AMVs on different cons, but never got an reply. So I think it would've been pointless. Nevertheless, its okay if he brings that forth, but that is no reason to bash on me for that because he is a judge.
This is my other AMV he commented on: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bv-pdr3FgSU
On this comment.... Well, my amv does have a storyline. Sure, for the people who dont know the anime it might be harder to follow/see, but it is present. And I think he is just being rude here.
I am not really sure what to do with it, but going to the staff of the AMV conventions wont do anything, because svandenboogaart (and sometimes Timmie too) are judges there. They have also been around the AMV scene of the dutch conventions for years, so they have connections with the hosts and such. I am considering to stop making AMVs for dutch conventions, because I have the feeling that the judges aren't editors themselves, and that they are a bit biased.
I would like to hear your opinion on this. You don't need to talk to them or anything, but I just want to know if I am in the wrong here, if I replied rudely or if my comments are justified.