
Nya-chan Production wrote:Limitations = bad for creativity. All or nothing.
NS wrote:This is like the stupidest topic ever. People should judge based on editing and editing alone, not on Source or combination or anything else.

gotegenks wrote:there are so many other factors in a video other than editing though, it can be hard to separate.
But whatever, it was a dumb idea, just thought it might be neat ><;

NS wrote:gotegenks wrote:there are so many other factors in a video other than editing though, it can be hard to separate.
But whatever, it was a dumb idea, just thought it might be neat ><;
Honestly, other then MAYBE concept (Thought this weighs heavily on the execution AKA editing of said concept)..there really AREN'T any other factors. If something is edited well then I like it...
gotegenks wrote:So basically you'd give them some extra points for using an old anime. (and a bunch of other nonsense about points)
With the existence of tiers, judges could forgo giving handicap points altogether. You'd know what you were getting into. It'd be a list of who's considered weaker, so if someone wanted to use a weaker source in a higher tier, then that's on them and not the judge.
And your statement of familiarity is completely irrelevant. If an editor is only familiar with old or bad animes and he does better with them than newer or good animes then he's already at a disadvantage as if his opponent is the typical editor these days then he's probably familiar with (at the very least) one of the EVA rebuilds or FF7.
So that actually supports the existence of tiers. The old-school anime lover can ic in some of the lower tiers where his lowly kenshin and YuYu stand a chance.
I'm not saying we should have tiers
if someone takes an anime you hate and puts it with a song you hate and edits it WONDERFULLY in a style you hate are you going to like it?
gotegenks wrote:NS wrote:gotegenks wrote:there are so many other factors in a video other than editing though, it can be hard to separate.
But whatever, it was a dumb idea, just thought it might be neat ><;
Honestly, other then MAYBE concept (Thought this weighs heavily on the execution AKA editing of said concept)..there really AREN'T any other factors. If something is edited well then I like it...
if someone takes an anime you hate and puts it with a song you hate and edits it WONDERFULLY in a style you hate are you going to like it?
gotegenks wrote:NS wrote:gotegenks wrote:there are so many other factors in a video other than editing though, it can be hard to separate.
But whatever, it was a dumb idea, just thought it might be neat ><;
Honestly, other then MAYBE concept (Thought this weighs heavily on the execution AKA editing of said concept)..there really AREN'T any other factors. If something is edited well then I like it...
if someone takes an anime you hate and puts it with a song you hate and edits it WONDERFULLY in a style you hate are you going to like it?


jaddziadax wrote:gotegenks wrote:I'm not saying we should have tiers
but you suggested it.
pwolf wrote:what someone likes is subjective so you can't assume everyone is going to like "newer" animes over "older" ones.
jaddziadax wrote:if someone takes an anime you hate and puts it with a song you hate and edits it WONDERFULLY in a style you hate are you going to like it?
There are some people out there who can appreciate things they dislike. I can see the talent and time and effort in a video where I dislike all the sources.

gotegenks wrote:Shit Tier - Elfen Lied


Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests