This thread may be getting hard to follow, so I'll try to shorten my posts and just refute the best arguments that are put forth against my position--the others I leave to the onlookers' reasoning capacities.
Since I last posted, DriftRoot has made two posts--I will deal primarily with the first, which was his response to me (while the second was to BasharOfTheAges).
My position: I take the Rec thread seriously, and I think "a narrative category should be implemented because it is really worthwhile."
I'm here to defend that position, and since the last exchange between DriftRoot and BasharOfTheAges doesn't focus on that too much, I'll stay uninvolved for now.
That said, on to the first of your two most recent posts, DriftRoot:
This is what I think the main point of your post was, and the best argument against my position:
The Narrative category should not be included in the Rec thread because it isn't clear-cut enough. People will disagree over whether or not a video is a Narrative video.
This would be a sound argument if we were talking about the average Narrative video. But we are not. We are talking about videos that would make it into the Rec forum. We are talking about the very best Narrative videos. If a video is so good at what it does--which is tell a story--that it can be considered the best in the Narrative field, then people won't be wondering if there's a story there or not.
They might not agree about whether or not it is a great story, but how good the story is doesn't matter. What matters is only how well the story is executed. I happen to dislike the story, "Romeo and Juliet" (because I oppose what the themes say about life), but I do not deny that it is particularly well-written.
New Recommended AMVs Topic: Narrative
-
- Joined: Fri May 09, 2008 11:06 am
- Org Profile
- guy07
- Joined: Mon Sep 08, 2003 1:28 pm
- Status: Back in beard.
- Location: T.O.
- Org Profile
Return to “Site Help & Feedback”
Jump to
- Announcements
- ↳ Site Announcements
- ↳ Rules & FAQs
- Community
- ↳ 2024 Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ AMV Documentary Project
- ↳ General Discussion
- Anime Music Videos
- ↳ General AMV
- ↳ Recommended AMVs
- ↳ AMV Monthly - {Currently on hiatus}
- ↳ AMV Announcements & Feedback
- ↳ Awaiting Catalog Entry
- ↳ Other Videos
- ↳ Works in Progress
- ↳ AMV Contests
- ↳ Org Supported Contests
- ↳ Active Contests
- ↳ 2024 Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ Contest Archives
- ↳ Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2023 Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2022 Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2021 Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2020 Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2019 Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2018 AnimeMusicVideos.org Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2017 AnimeMusicVideos.org Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2016 AnimeMusicVideos.org Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2015 AnimeMusicVideos.org Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2014 AnimeMusicVideos.org Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2013 AnimeMusicVideos.Org Viewer's Choice Awards
- ↳ 2012 AnimeMusicVideos.org Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2011 AnimeMusicVideos.org Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2010 AnimeMusicVideos.org Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2009 AnimeMusicVideos.org Viewers' Choice Awards
- ↳ 2008 AnimeMusicVideo.org Viewer's Choice Awards
- ↳ VCA Shameless Promotion Archives
- ↳ VCA Shameless Promotions 2007
- ↳ VCA Shameless Promotions 2006
- ↳ VCA Shameless Promotions 2005
- ↳ VCA Shameless Promotions 2004
- ↳ VCA Shameless Promotions 2003
- ↳ Project Org Editor
- ↳ Project Org Editor 2022
- ↳ Project Org Editor 2020
- ↳ Project Org Editor 2016
- ↳ Project Org Editor 2015
- ↳ Project Editor: Tag Team Trials
- ↳ Project OrgEditor Season 3: The King of Spring
- ↳ Project OrgEditor Season 2
- ↳ Project OrgEditor Season 1
- ↳ AMV Roulette
- ↳ AMV Roulette 2016
- ↳ AMV Roulette 2015
- ↳ AMV Roulette 2014
- ↳ The Quickening
- ↳ The Quickening 2015
- ↳ The Quickening 2014
- ↳ The Quickening 2013
- ↳ The Quickening 2012
- ↳ Team Warfare
- ↳ The Online AMV Iron Chef Tournament v4.0
- ↳ Multi-Editor Projects
- Anime
- ↳ General Anime
- ↳ Anime Screencaps
- ↳ Anime Series Discussion
- ↳ Anime Conventions
- Editing & Technology
- ↳ Video & Audio Help
- ↳ Capturing / Ripping Help
- ↳ Conversion / Encoding Help
- ↳ AviSynth Help
- ↳ VapourSynth Help
- ↳ Video Editing Software
- ↳ Adobe Software
- ↳ Movie Studio & Vegas Pro
- ↳ Windows Movie Maker
- ↳ Mac Software
- ↳ Effects & Techniques
- ↳ Guides & Tutorials
- ↳ Hardware Discussion
- Web Site
- ↳ Site Help & Feedback
- ↳ Org Redesign
- ↳ Moderator Drop Box
- ↳ Heads Up!
- ↳ Video Software Help Archive
- ↳ How To Defeat the Fire Lord
- ↳ Penguin Sledding
- ↳ Avatar The Last Airbender
- ↳ Unobtainium Harvesting Help
- ↳ Website Archive
- ↳ General Off Topic
- ↳ It's all about me!