I myself am not a creator but I do like to write reviews sometimes. So I don't think limiting reviews to just creators is a great idea.
P.S. - Punistation, you never asked me to do a review
TaranT wrote:mexicanjunior wrote:Honestly, I see nothing wrong with the current review system to warrant overhauling it. It's fair and accurate in my eyes.
You are being sarcastic, aren't you? :?
http://www.animemusicvideos.org/legacy/opinion_info.php?vid_id=6527
Isn't it obvious that the reviews need to be moderated the same way and for the same reason that forum posts should be (or will be?) ?
flint_the_dwarf wrote:Hmm... yeah people generally seem to like being unsatisfied with stuff.
mexicanjunior wrote:There's exceptions to everything and an all 1's review is certainly worthy of being deleted by Phade because no video really deserves it....A minor tweak here and there is fine but a complete revamp is unneccssary IMHO.
Zarxrax wrote:...Instead, people would use the opinions more for what they were actually designed for - giving helpful feedback to the videos creator.
TaranT: The quick solution for the 10% list is to raise the threshold opinion count to something like 200 instead of 3.
Phade wrote:Hey,
Finally the site is stable for more than 20 mins...
Anyways, the thumb scale has been an idea for quite some time. I was going to have it available for v.2, but I didn't get around to it in time for the rollout. I even had text referring to it that I had to remove since it's not here yet.TaranT: The quick solution for the 10% list is to raise the threshold opinion count to something like 200 instead of 3.
The reason it is at 3 is so you can more quickly find what other people think is a good video. If you don't think it's good, post your honest opinion saying so. There is nothing wrong with an honest opinion.
As for who pushed for the top 10% in the begining, I won't say directly, but leave it up to you to research it when the old forum is back up in read-only mode; you may be suprised.
Phade.
Phade wrote:As for who pushed for the top 10% in the begining, I won't say directly, but leave it up to you to research it when the old forum is back up in read-only mode; you may be suprised.
Return to Site Help & Feedback
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest