I Just Don't Get It

This forum is for the general discussion of Music.

Postby downwithpants » Tue Oct 10, 2006 12:38 am

personally:
there isn't any music genre that I can state reasons for why I like it without:
-overgeneralizing the genre
-overgeneralizing my feelings toward the genre
or
-giving overgeneralized reasons that aren't specific to that genre

i don't like music just because it's a certain genre. i like certain musical pieces of several different genres for various reasons.

there are situations where i prefer some genres to others (this goes back to the genre-specific function of music), and where i prefer some songs within some genres to others.
maskandlayer()|My Guide to WMM 2.x
a-m-v.org Last.fm|<a href="http://www.frappr.com/animemusicvideosdotorg">Animemusicvideos.org Frappr</a>|<a href="http://tinyurl.com/2lryta"> Editors and fans against the misattribution of AMVs</a>
User avatar
downwithpants
BIG PICTURE person
 
Joined: 03 Dec 2002
Location: storrs, ct
Status: out of service

Postby Otohiko » Tue Oct 10, 2006 12:45 am

HeavyMetal wrote:Articulate response, but the question really is what does other music have to offer?


I think your first problem is that you already have a pre-conceived notion of what music should offer and your view of quality. There is no such thing as singular quality in music which is measurable and applies equally to everything; there is on the other hand many, often incompatible qualities.

It's useless trying to compare metal to the generic 'non-metal' because there are fundamentally different qualities at play here.

Whether you've grown into metal or metal has grown into your notion of quality in music, with your approach you'll never get to anything other than metal - because the qualities you're looking for are essentially on the metal plane. In fact some types of music are even based on completely different attitudes and value systems. You're not going to get much out of other genres of music while approaching them with a mindset that's fixed on an incompatible perception of what constitutes quality.

Let's look at your list:
I like Metal. Why:

Passionate Lyrics
Powerful Bass
Wild Antics
Wide Range of Songs
Wide Range of Fans
Enormous Shows
Legendary Characters
Interesting People
Inventive Styles
Adrenalin Pounding Music


You realize this list could apply in a slightly different plane to anything from jazz to punk to prog rock? I fail to see what defines 'passionate' lyrics on a genre basis. Same goes for the others. They're all not just debatable, they're applicable across a very wide cross-section of generic rock (and even non-rock) music.
Otohiko
 
Joined: 05 May 2003

Postby HeavyMetal » Tue Oct 10, 2006 5:23 pm

I'm not saying I like metal, because its metal. (ewww at all the terrible bands that claimed metal at some point. Even M. Bolton tried for metal at one point. ahhhh.)


Yes I realize about my list, but together it applies mostly to metal. I happen to like other genre when they have some of those features.

I'm not looking to compare anything. I used metal as my example because metal is what I like. It is just that an EXAMPLE.

I kept my list simple because everytime I elaborate to much somebody gets caught in the words and misses the point. Sound familiar.

No music does not breakdown to a set number attributes, but such attributes are that can be measured. I can't measure a musical spiritual high, but I can measure the elements of its source.

I hate such quantitative measuring sticks, but qualitive gets overly simple answers that are worse than generic if any explanation at all.

Your conception of pre-conceived of notions is even more off. I looked at metal to come up with that list so no shit it looks like a metal set of parameters.

I am asking for someone to explain the values in other music by a simple standard or an internal standard I care not which. I just hope somebody can actually give an answer rather than your question sucks cuz it too hard, you stupid response.
HeavyMetal
 
Joined: 24 Jan 2004

Postby Iamshadowkiller » Tue Oct 10, 2006 5:29 pm

The reason your question sucks is not because it's "too hard".

I think that if you believe, really believe that there is a definite answer to your question, then perhaps it's time to think hard on just what exactly it is you like and why you like it, before you start questioning everyone else.

And before you start responding to me with your defensive mumbo jumbo, just save it, it's too long and really makes no sense.

/end
Oh how convenient. A theory about God that doesn't require looking through a telescope.
User avatar
Iamshadowkiller
 
Joined: 14 Sep 2001
Location: Your Mother
Status: Pending

Postby nailz » Tue Oct 10, 2006 6:05 pm

Music that is not Metal offers the same thing banana's do..

A healthy dose of potassium.
Ploink! Magic Cupcake! <a href="http://www.elvenking.net">Elvenking</a>. I'm sorry, I can't hear you over how awesome I am.
User avatar
nailz
 
Joined: 04 Jun 2001
Location: Phoenix AZ

Postby R-A-N-M-A » Tue Oct 10, 2006 8:41 pm

Define metal.
- New Banner in the Works -

Still Johnny Fish
User avatar
R-A-N-M-A
 
Joined: 18 Aug 2002
Location: General Music Forum

Postby Flint the Dwarf » Tue Oct 10, 2006 9:24 pm

Image

Image

Which of these do you find emotional? And in what ways? What inspires the emotion? Which has more appealing qualities?

Can you explain to me why Jackson Pollock is a more emotional artist than Caravaggio? You can't. The compositions are too different. Pollock doesn't draw your eye anywhere, everything is sprawled out in front of you. And if someone were to tell you precisely what the appeal to Pollack's art was, would you understand it? It's still just a mass of swirling colors, however easy it is to see chaos or anger or even tranquillity in various parts of his art. With Caravaggio it's more defined. The eye is drawn to the white flesh of Christ, and the surrounding black contrasts. Everyone around him is in motion, clearly mourning. It's almost mathematical. And if someone were to find a lack of genuinity in this almost mathematical process of art, who are you to find fault in that?

Some things you just have to accept without a definite, satisfying explanation. Art is subjective, and everyone will find different aspects appealing. If you still persist in thinking that metal has enough to offer to sate everyone's appetite, I don't see how I can persuade you otherwise. At least consider that yes, while metal offers immense diversity, it doesn't always offer that diversity in large enough quantity to satisfy what someone's looking for. Other genres do offer that, and thank god.
Kusoyaro: We don't need a leader. We need to SHUT UP. Make what you want to make, don't make you what you don't want to make. If neither of those applies to you, then you need to SHUT UP MORE.
User avatar
Flint the Dwarf
 
Joined: 16 Jan 2002
Location: Ashland, WI

Postby madbunny » Tue Oct 10, 2006 9:42 pm

While you've refined your question a few times, the original question as stated is kind of retarded. You might as well be asking why anybody would bother listening to anything other than Country Music, as it contains pretty much the same things.


The FUNCTION of art is to evoke emotion, or trigger some kind of reaction. Your milage will vary. It's a given that a lot of the time this fails abysmally, but that's fwhat it's supposed to do. That's also one of the reasons that 'classic rock' stations are always updating their music to about 20 years ago. It's designed to appeal to a certain age bracket. So, yes, in 2010 you'll be hearing matchbox 20 and linkin' park on the classic stations.

You've obviously been enamoured of your chosen musical style, and find it appealing for whatever reason (perhaps the guitar solos, perhaps the in your facy lyric style). You mention Def Leppard a couple times. Interestingly enough, Leppard isn't what most people would consider metal, though it has some of the same elements, in the same way that some Peter Frampton songs have some of the same elements yet would also not be considered metal.


On to my actual response on why I like what I do:

I listen to 'almost' anything. Seriously. When most people say that, what they really mean is that they don't cry and moan when something they are not used to gets played, even though all their personal music is mostly of one type (metal for instance). I listen to what reflects my mood, unless I'm feeling EMO, which is just wrong, so I'll play something cheerful, like country music, or cartoon soundtracks. When I'm at work, I play everything from Linkin park, Korn, Trapt, William Shatner, Beethoven, tons of soundtracks like Passion, and mortal combat, and Shania Twain in my room.

At home.. pretty much whatever perks my mood. AMVs tend to influence that alot, thus I'm accumulating a lot of Jpop. In the car.. mostly classic rock, or progressive rock unless my wife wants to listen to NPR.
Build a man a fire, and he will be warm for a night. Set a man on fire, and he will be warm for the rest of his life.
User avatar
madbunny
 
Joined: 17 Jun 2003

Postby HeavyMetal » Tue Oct 10, 2006 10:27 pm

I can list exactly why I like metal. Nobody else has offered shit for reason why they like something not why I should. If you don't want two way communication shadowkiller don't post. Your piss poor psych analysis is not relevant to the topic.

The question is always the same what value do you find in your music.
From the start it was about understanding another view point not my own. Thats been done years ago. (I keep rephrasing the question toward a better connection with a relatively unknown audience.)

No more drugs for nails. haha

Im not defining metal. I could as I did it by analysis to my own satisfaction, but it is a muddy subject often prowled by total assholes.

Yes Flint art is subjective, but it is made of elements and people can describe a preference beyond simply I like it.


THIS IS NOT ABOUT METAL. Metal was the example because after sampling about every music you can imagine, that is what I liked most. But apparently I am the only jackass on the planet that knows his own tastes and drives.


YEAH for Madbunny. Somebody that has a basis for a selection. Holy crap I think we found the holy grail. Not genre explicative, but thanks for actually getting the point. Kickass. Reason = Selection.

Madbunny recieves awesomeness award.


Lets try a non-musical comparison for everyone else.

Videogames have much more polar characteristics so perhaps that will help.

Type - Typical point of Interest

2D Fighting - Childhood Memory, Quick Action, Simple Controls
3D Fighting - More realistic fights, intense action, more complex controls
RPG - Compelling Story
MMORPG - Interaction, Neverending
Puzzles - Interactive and Thought Provoking
Platformer - Action with Story to various combinations

Each game has its own merits beyond its genre, but it will likely share characteristics that draw repeated fans. Same with any art form.

Parts equalling more than the whole may yet be beyond the grasp of reason, but the parts themselves are not.
HeavyMetal
 
Joined: 24 Jan 2004

Postby Flint the Dwarf » Tue Oct 10, 2006 10:43 pm

Wait, wait, you honestly needed someone to tell you that they listen to varying music depending on their mood? What the hell? You need this shit spoon fed to you? I really don't see what you aren't understanding.

Okay, you've listed elements of why you like metal, and I think pretty much anyone who's brought up any point has basically said that those same elements are present in pretty much any kind of music. So what are you waiting for someone to say? Me, I'm a metalhead, but I have no problem understanding why people like other music. Why they prefer other music. Do you really need someone to come out here and say that they like the content of lyrics or the emotion or the arrangement of instruments or the composition or production or type of instrument used or vocal melody? Because all those elements are in any genre of music, but with a different emphasis. Maybe that's what you need to understand.

Either way, I'm done with this. Until you can further clarify your non-understanding, I don't see how anyone can answer.
Kusoyaro: We don't need a leader. We need to SHUT UP. Make what you want to make, don't make you what you don't want to make. If neither of those applies to you, then you need to SHUT UP MORE.
User avatar
Flint the Dwarf
 
Joined: 16 Jan 2002
Location: Ashland, WI

Postby Iamshadowkiller » Wed Oct 11, 2006 12:07 am

HeavyMetal wrote:If you don't want two way communication shadowkiller don't post. Your piss poor psych analysis is not relevant to the topic.


there you did it again, why the long responses with the annoying spaces and poor structure? you're not really saying anything

also, I'm not trying to analyze anything, we can all agree that you've changed your question many times and don't even seem to know why exactly you like metal, you've just been disagreeing with anyone, what you've been asking for is a definitive answer that doesn't exist, stop it with your supposed logic and what I guess you believe to be really intelligent responses, this is not the first time that I've seen your posts and well...I guess i will now stop posting here as well, this is the internet after all...insert a comparison to the special olympics where it fits.

/end
Oh how convenient. A theory about God that doesn't require looking through a telescope.
User avatar
Iamshadowkiller
 
Joined: 14 Sep 2001
Location: Your Mother
Status: Pending

Postby wurpess » Wed Oct 11, 2006 12:41 am

I like metal. It's shiny and pretty. I also like elves. They're neat. And they make me cookies. I like cookies. I also like arguments. Just not when they're silly and pointless. Except if I'm that bored. I also like being different. It's boring when everything's the same. Like music. If everything sounded the same, that would be silly. . .and boring. HOORAY FOR DIVERSITY!!!!!!!!!! WEHOO!!!! :D Because of diversity, stuff will distract me from staring at the walls for hours on end and makes me feel all warm and fuzzy. . . .or like killing stuff. But hey, it makes life more interesting. FWEEEEEEEE!!!! :idea:
ImageImage
User avatar
wurpess
rabid fangirl
 
Joined: 28 Mar 2005
Location: The happy place in my head
Status: BLAAAARGH!!!!! -_-

Postby R-A-N-M-A » Wed Oct 11, 2006 1:03 am

This thread is going dangerously down hill. It has down graded from an attempt to explain that opinion is simply opinion and yours applies to no one elses into a god damned pissing match about whose opinion on opinion is more sound.
- New Banner in the Works -

Still Johnny Fish
User avatar
R-A-N-M-A
 
Joined: 18 Aug 2002
Location: General Music Forum

Postby CerebralAssamite » Wed Oct 11, 2006 1:10 am

R-A-N-M-A wrote:This thread is going dangerously down hill. It has down graded from an attempt to explain that opinion is simply opinion and yours applies to no one elses into a god damned pissing match about whose opinion on opinion is more sound.


I always thought that Opinions were like assholes, everybody has one.

ORLY!!!

YA RLY!!!
User avatar
CerebralAssamite
 
Joined: 12 Jun 2004
Location: You Mean You Care?

Postby downwithpants » Wed Oct 11, 2006 4:03 am

HeavyMetal wrote:what value do you find in your music.


oh, the underlying values i look for in music are (roughly in descending importance):
-chord progression that flows naturally yet evokes some emotion, sensation, or idea
-stylized ornamentations of any musical element (such as rhythm, melody, or timbre)
-quality of performance
-if it's a recording, quality of production (recording, sound engineering)
-tricks like counterpoint, polyphony, and polymeter always impress me
-lyrical content is probably of least importance to me

but as you may notice, none of these are specific to any genre.
maskandlayer()|My Guide to WMM 2.x
a-m-v.org Last.fm|<a href="http://www.frappr.com/animemusicvideosdotorg">Animemusicvideos.org Frappr</a>|<a href="http://tinyurl.com/2lryta"> Editors and fans against the misattribution of AMVs</a>
User avatar
downwithpants
BIG PICTURE person
 
Joined: 03 Dec 2002
Location: storrs, ct
Status: out of service

PreviousNext

Return to Music Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest