Um...
Well, opinions are opinions.
I.
When I say
complicated, I don't mean good music. And yes, they would have to be programmed. You would need to program the equations and algorhythms neccesary to generate proper, literate music from randomized values. For instance, I have personally witnessed a musician write a fugue based on a given melodic theme, and explain to me how this was primarily a logical, mathematical process.
A computer is much better suited to writing complicated music. For instance, take the 11/32 rhythm you mentioned - as people, we are naturally adjusted to 4/4, it's programed into us on a biological level. So, something with an outlandish signature like that is really a struggle for us to properly understand and accept - thus making it a bit difficult to create. But it's a very mathematical thing, and computers are good at that. Plus, they have no rhythms or any musical knowledge programmed into them, and have no obstacles in carrying out the calculations.
But will a computer ever write a great fugue? No. Because it doesn't have a natural feel for music, an emotional association to it that we as humans do.
You yourself suggested that complex does not equal great. So, I don't believe there's any contradiction or misjudgement on my part.
II.
I consider myself to be the most open-minded person I know. Heck, I even enjoyed Linkin Ball Z videos for a time - despite my dislike of both - until they got repetitive. Music is an extremely sensitive area for me - so I listen to it with a most open mind. Anything that is well-done with a good intention and proper placement gets a nod from me. For one, you won't hear me bitching about J-Pop in anime.
III.
Regarding my opinion. I don't mean to purposely convert everyone to my evil music agenda, but do not think that I come unprepared into a discussion. Firstly, I come from a family background which includes a professional musician of 25 years.
Secondly, note some passages written in
italics throughout my statements. These are not mine. These are paraphrases of quotes by a very forward, influential musician of our time who has written much about the philosophy of music, and has been in the frontline for the past 40 years. Thus, these opinions are not too narrow-minded or ill-supported.
IV.
Oh God! Geirr is right where I'm coming from. Good to hear
I also have a thing against songs. I think of them as an easy way out.
---
Again, remember, don't hate me
